Common Misconceptions About Canadian Criminal Law
Source: https://www.pexels.com/photo/judges-desk-with-gavel-and-scales-5669619/
Canada, known for its stunning landscapes and a highly integrated economy with extensive trade ties, often faces misconceptions about its legal system. While the US and Canada are direct neighbors and share a mutual history with British Common Law, their criminal law systems have some significant differences.
Popular media, including legal dramas, have created these misconceptions about Canada's criminal justice system and blurred the lines between reality and fiction. Let’s look into some common misconceptions surrounding Canadian Criminal Law:
1. Miranda vs. Charter Rights
If you’ve ever watched a law-oriented television show, you may be familiar with the Miranda Rights statement, “You have the right to remain silent”. However, these rights are only specific to the United States. When you’re arrested in Canada, the police will inform you of your rights under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The police will usually ask you these or similarly framed, four yes-or-no questions:
● Do you understand why you’re being arrested?
● Do you understand you have the right to consult with a lawyer?
● Do you want to talk to a lawyer?
● Do you understand that anything you say can be used as evidence in court?
While these are similar to Miranda Rights, Charter Rights are a more interactive process that ensures you understand your rights and not just hear them recited.
2. You Always Need a Warrant for an Arrest
While typically, a warrant is required for the police to enter your home, a warrantless arrest can also occur in some exceptions, and there is nothing wrong with it. According to the Justice Laws Website of Canada, if the police are in hot pursuit of someone, they have the right to arrest that person, and if that person runs into a home, the police can follow them inside without needing a warrant.
The police can also enter the house without a warrant if they have a good reason to believe a serious crime is happening inside the house, for example, a violent fight reported on a 911 call. The police are allowed to skip the warrant if the informed consent of a grown-up (spouse, roommate, or parent) has been granted. There are also additional special laws that permit police to enter a home without a warrant, for example, when they think someone might be dead inside.
3. Obligation to Answer
The law protects your right to stay silent during a criminal investigation. You don’t have to answer any questions, especially before speaking to a lawyer. Silence is a good course of action because anything you say can be used against you in court.
While staying silent might seem safe, some worry that it can be misconstrued as guilt. However, remember, silence is not an admission of guilt. It’s your right. However, lying to the police is a crime. When you’re unsure, it's best to politely inform the officer you wish to remain silent and request a lawyer. You can get help from trustworthy firms like Liberty Law to help you appoint skilled lawyers to guide and defend you when facing criminal charges and other offenses.
Endnote
These are just some of the many misconceptions about Canadian criminal laws. The next time you watch a legal drama, remember it is only for entertainment and is quite far from reality. It is also optimal to be aware of your rights if you’re either visiting or are already a resident of Canada. Do not hesitate to consult a legal professional for advice upon any doubt. They can clear out confusion in easy and plain language and help you navigate the situation more wisely.
